Appeal Could Ease Harassment Proof for Teaching Aides

Teaching assistants at Philadelphia schools may face a different liability standard depending on how the Third Circuit rules.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Education

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain brick and granite institutional facade with empty steps, in oxblood and cream, evoking the weight of a legal question about university liability.
A federal appeals court heard arguments on November 18, 2025, over whether a former University of Pennsylvania teaching assistant can hold the university liable for alleged harassment under a negligence standard. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

A federal appeals court heard oral arguments on November 18, 2025, in a sexual harassment lawsuit brought by a former University of Pennsylvania teaching assistant against the university. The suit alleges violations of Title VII and a Philadelphia ordinance, and a federal district court had earlier granted Penn summary judgment.

Why it matters

The case asks whether universities can be held liable for harassment on campus without proof they knew about it, a question that could shape how Philadelphia-area schools handle complaints from student workers. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has backed a negligence standard in a February 2026 amicus brief, and the outcome could change what graduate workers must prove.

The lawsuit was filed in March 2025 and alleges violations of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act and the Philadelphia Fair Practices Ordinance. The plaintiff's counsel hopes the appeals court will reverse and send the case to trial.

The players

University of Pennsylvania

A large private research university in Philadelphia with substantial graduate and student-employment programs, and the defendant in this case.

U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission

The federal agency that enforces workplace discrimination law, including Title VII, and that filed the amicus brief in this appeal.

Third Circuit Court of Appeals

The federal appeals court that heard oral arguments in the case and will decide whether to reverse the lower-court ruling.

The details

The plaintiff worked as a part-time teaching assistant for an assistant professor and says she was harassed by a male student while on the job. A March 2023 return-to-work letter stated the alleged harasser could still interact with her in the academic setting, and she argues Penn's student services did not provide adequate remediation. The district court concluded she did not cite evidence a reasonable jury could use to find the university liable, and the appeal now tests whether a negligence standard should apply instead.

Timeline

  1. March 2023: A return-to-work letter permitted the alleged harasser to interact with the plaintiff in the academic setting.

  2. March 2025: The lawsuit was filed in federal court.

  3. October 2025: A federal judge granted summary judgment in Penn's favor.

  4. November 18, 2025: The Third Circuit heard oral arguments.

  5. February 2026: The EEOC filed an amicus brief requesting adoption of a negligence standard.

Education Landscape

Campus harassment cases involving graduate and student workers have drawn growing attention as universities rely on teaching assistants for undergraduate instruction. This appeal follows a pattern of courts deciding how much notice an institution must have before it becomes liable under federal and local anti-discrimination law.

Graduate and undergraduate students who work as teaching assistants should know that harassment complaints may be judged differently depending on whether the school had notice of the conduct. Students working as teaching assistants can ask their school's Title IX or student-employment office how complaints are handled and what protections apply to them.

The takeaway

The appeal could set a clearer standard for when universities are responsible for harassment involving student workers. Anyone working as a teaching assistant can ask their campus office how complaints are reported and what supports exist.

Further reading

For more on the schools shaping this region, see Higher Education coverage across Philadelphia.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Former Penn President Liz Magill earned $4.46 million the year following her resignation - The Daily Pennsylvanian.