Columbia Leads NYC College Reputation Poll

Prospective New York City students and families get a local voter view of which universities rank highest for reputation.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Education

Columbia Leads NYC College Reputation Poll

Live Poll

Would you pick a college mainly for its reputation over its cost?

A Honan Strategy Group poll of 1,302 likely New York City general election voters ranked Columbia University first for best overall reputation among city universities, with 29% of voters choosing it. NYU placed second with 13%, and 31% of respondents said they didn't know.

Why it matters

For New York City students weighing where to apply, reputation rankings like this one shape how families compare local options alongside selectivity and cost. The poll reflects local voters' perceptions rather than an objective measure of academic quality.

The poll surveyed 1,302 likely NYC general election voters, with Columbia receiving 29% of votes and NYU 13%. Columbia's 2025-26 common data reported its largest-ever entering undergraduate class.

The players

Columbia University

A large private Ivy League research university in Manhattan, ranked first in the poll for reputation among New York City schools.

New York University (NYU)

A large private research university in New York City that placed second in the poll for reputation.

Honan Strategy Group

A New York political and strategy research firm that conducted the '5 Borough Barometer' poll.

The details

The poll was titled the '5 Borough Barometer' and asked respondents which college or university has the best overall reputation. Respondents could name any institution, and the results were tallied into percentage shares. Columbia ranked first with 29% and the Honan Strategy Group survey placed NYU second with 13%. Because 31% of voters said they did not know, the rankings reflect a substantial share of undecided respondents.

Timeline

  1. Nov. 1, 2026: Early decision application deadline for NYC and state colleges passed.

  2. 2025-26: Columbia admitted its largest-ever entering undergraduate class, according to its common data.

  3. Nov. 12, 2026: Honan Strategy Group poll results were published.

Education Landscape

The Princeton Review's dream-college survey also placed Columbia and NYU in its top 10, so local voter perceptions align with a national survey of prospective students. Columbia's growth to its largest-ever entering class reflects continued demand for selective New York institutions.

If you are applying to New York City colleges, reputation rankings are one input among many, alongside program fit, cost, and admissions criteria. Ask each school's admissions or financial-aid office about the specific programs and aid options you are considering.

The takeaway

Reputation polls capture how local voters see universities, but they do not measure teaching quality or fit for an individual student. Before deciding, compare schools on the programs, costs, and aid packages that matter most to you, and confirm details directly with each school's admissions office.

Further reading

For a broader look at choosing among schools, explore College Applications guidance for New York City students.

Source note: This article includes information reported by AmNewYork.

Live Poll

Would you pick a college mainly for its reputation over its cost?