Judge Weighs Speech Rights for Non-Tenured Faculty

Non-tenured faculty at Atlanta schools should check how their institution's speech policies interact with termination rules.

Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Education

Judge Weighs Speech Rights for Non-Tenured Faculty

Live Poll

Should employers fire workers for controversial opinions they post on personal social media?

A former Emory University pediatrics professor is suing the school for breach of contract after being fired in 2025 over a Facebook comment about Charlie Kirk's killing. Emory has asked a judge to dismiss the case, and the judge has not yet ruled on that motion.

Why it matters

For Atlanta students and faculty, the case tests how much discretion universities hold to end a professor's appointment when the professor lacks tenure and the dismissal is tied to off-campus speech. The outcome could shape how Emory's own free-expression policy is read in future disputes.

The professor was an associate professor who had no tenure at the time of her termination, a status central to Emory's argument that its policies give the university sole discretion over ending a professor's employment. The judge has set no ruling date on the motion to dismiss.

The players

Emory University

A private research university in Atlanta, Georgia, with a large medical school and a substantial research and tuition-driven budget.

Earl Leroy Carter

A U.S. Representative from Georgia who publicly called for federal funds to be withheld from Emory until faculty he described as hate-filled are fired.

The details

The former professor claims her dismissal broke Emory's Open Expression policy, and she is pursuing the case as a breach-of-contract claim rather than a free-speech claim. Emory's attorney, Sterling Gardner Culpepper, argues that university policies give the school sole discretion over termination, so the court must decide whether those policies bind the university to a review process before a non-tenured faculty member can be let go. Emory's own standing committee reached a finding that the school of medicine failed to give substantial consideration before the termination, which the professor is relying on in her filing.

Timeline

  1. September 2025: Charlie Kirk was killed at Utah Valley University.

  2. 2025: The former professor was fired by Emory University.

  3. May 2026: The professor filed the breach-of-contract lawsuit against Emory.

  4. Friday, November 2026: The judge declined to rule on Emory's motion to dismiss.

Education Landscape

Disputes over faculty speech have grown more visible as campuses face political pressure from both sides, and non-tenured professors typically have fewer contractual protections than tenured colleagues. This case sits at the intersection of those two trends, testing how far a university's written speech policy constrains its power to end an appointment.

If you are a student or family member weighing a university's free-expression commitments, read the school's written policies and ask the admissions or student affairs office how faculty and student speech complaints are handled. Students at non-tenured-faculty-heavy programs may want to ask how continuity of instruction is protected if an instructor is removed mid-term.

The takeaway

The case shows that a written speech policy and a university's termination authority can point in different directions, and courts often decide which one controls. Students and families can ask any school how its faculty appointment and speech policies interact before enrolling, since the answer shapes the stability of the instruction they receive.

Further reading

For more on how faculty employment protections work at Atlanta-area schools, explore Higher Education coverage on Scholaroo.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Court House News Service.

Live Poll

Should employers fire workers for controversial opinions they post on personal social media?